|
Commercial development will occur in the forms of 1) upgrading and intensification of present commercial areas
and 2) expansion to vacant, commercially designated properties. Upgrading and intensification will occur in downtown,
Glenbrook, and the Pine Creek complex, as well as commercial strips along East Main, South Auburn, and Highway
174. Some expansion of the existing commercial areas will occur in or near Glenbrook and Pine Creek. New expansion
sites include 22 acres at Kenny Ranch, the North Star Central Business District (CBD) (commercial allocation per
annexation agreement), and Railroad Avenue/Idaho Maryland Road and at the 70 acre Bear River Mill site bounded
by Highway 49 and La Barr Meadows Road.
The current General Plan was adopted in 1982. Thus, the current General Plan has been "in place" for
17 years, within the 15 to 25 year planning "horizon" recommended by California Government Code §65300.
Several factors led to an update the General Plan at this time. The pace of growth and development has been slower
than that projected in the 1982 General Plan, causing discrepancies between Plan policies and actual circumstances.
Certain developments were not adequately anticipated by the current General Plan, notably the establishment of
Sierra College. Certain General Plan elements had been updated or added since 1982, including the Housing Element,
and were determined to be sufficiently current. Others, it was determined by City decision-makers, needed revision
to reflect actual conditions, assure internal consistency among the General Plan Elements, and provide an opportunity
for the City and its citizens to forge new directions as the City approached the Year 2000.
2.3 RELATED ACTIONS AND INTENDED USES OF THE EIR
The draft Grass Valley General Plan will be refined through the public review and public hearing process. The
final Grass Valley General Plan will be considered for a recommendation of approval by the Grass Valley
Planning Commission and officially adopted and implemented by the Grass Valley City Council.
The EIR will serve at least two major purposes. First, it will inform the City's decision-makers (i.e., Planning
Commission, City Council) and the public of the potential environmental consequences of adopting the General Plan.
Secondly, all subsequent discretionary actions under the Plan, such as the adoption of specific plans and specific
development projects, will require CEQA documentation. Because this EIR is structured as a Program EIR that addresses
subsequent actions that are likely to occur under the Plan, this EIR serves as a basis for "tiering."
Under the tiering concept provided in §15385 of the CEQA Guidelines, these subsequent CEQA documents
may "tier" off the programmatic General Plan EIR by incorporating by reference the general environmental
information provided in this document and focusing narrowly on those project or site-specific issues not fully
addressed in this program EIR. It is also intended that the General Plan EIR be used in accordance with §15183
of the CEQA Guidelines allowing streamlined review of projects fully assessed in the General Plan EIR.
Agencies that will use this EIR include the Planning Commission and City Council in their deliberations on land
use proposals under the Plan. Other agencies may utilize this document to ensure that their plans and activities
in the Grass Valley Planning Area conform to the goals, objectives, policies, implementation actions and strategies
and mitigation measures presented in this document. Such plans may need to be amended to achieve General Plan consistency.
An action directly related to Plan adoption will be review and amendment, if necessary, of the Grass Valley
Zoning Ordinance and subdivision regulations.
2.4 GENERAL PLAN ALTERNATIVES
2.4.1 No Project Alternative
Given the nature of a general plan update, there is more than one way to characterize the "no project"
alternative. For a simple development project, such as a residential subdivision, the "no project" alternative
simply assumes that the development will not be constructed. The potential environmental effects of not constructing
such a project can then easily be compared to the potential effects of construction and occupation of the project.
However, with regard to a general plan update, the situation is somewhat less straightforward.
California planning law requires each local (i.e., county or incorporated city) government to maintain a general
plan and periodically update it with public input. Therefore, it is not realistic to assume that "no project"
in this case means a situation in which the City decides to operate from this moment forward with no general plan.
The California General Plan Guidelines Chapter 4, page 107 states as follows:
The EIR must also evaluate the "no project" alternative. This would describe what physical changes
might reasonably be expected to occur in the foreseeable future if the general plan update were not adopted, based
on the existing general plan and available infrastructure and services.
Similarly, Section 15126.6(e)(3)(A) of the CEQA Guidelines states:
"When the project is the revision of an existing land use or regulatory plan, policy or ongoing operation,
the "no project" alternative will be the continuation of the existing plan, policy or operation into
the future. Typically this is a situation where other projects initiated under the existing plan will continue
while the new plan is developed. Thus, the projected impacts of the proposed plan or alternative plans would be
compared to the impacts that would occur under the existing plan."
Therefore, the "no project" alternative is considered a continuation of the existing 1982 Grass Valley
General Plan. This alternative compares the build-out of the 1982 General Plan with the 2020 development scenario
of the proposed General Plan Update (The existing Grass Valley General Plan is incorporated by reference and is
available for review at the Grass Valley Community Development Department, 125 E. Main Street, Grass Valley).
2.4.2 Northerly Emphasis Alternative
The Northerly Emphasis seeks to maintain a tight development pattern, minimizing urban sprawl.
The Northerly Emphasis assigns future development to the north and east of downtown as much as possible. By
steering growth accordingly, most new development will be 1) within the Wolf Creek watershed (efficient provision
and extension of infrastructure, especially wastewater, storm drainage, recreation, and circulation facilities)
and 2) convenient to downtown, Glenbrook, the Litton/Sierra College complex, and existing industrial and business
parks. Gravity flow of the vast majority of wastewater from new developments to the City wastewater treatment plant
on Freeman Lane/Wolf Creek is accomplished under this Alternative.
Significant transportation improvements, including non-vehicular facilities (bikeways, sidewalks, trails) as
well as street and highways improvements, must facilitate circulation, especially within the triangle formed by
Brunswick Road, East Bennett, and the Freeway. Vehicular access to downtown from the east, a new interchange at
Dorsey or vicinity, and connections between Idaho-Maryland Road and East Bennett are all likely transportation
improvements resulting in part from the Northerly Emphasis.
By shifting development north, and closer to established neighborhoods of southwestern Grass Valley, the extension
of City services and infrastructure is facilitated. This includes gravity flow from North Star residential areas
to the wastewater treatment plant.
The Loma Rica Ranch and Kenny Ranch annexation areas will develop per annexation agreements (refer to Table
2-1).
Commercial development will occur as 1) upgrading and intensification of present commercial areas and 2) expansion
to vacant, commercially designated properties. Upgrading and intensification will occur in downtown, Glenbrook,
and the Pine Creek complex, as well as commercial strips along East Main, South Auburn, and Highway 174. Some expansion
will occur in or near Glenbrook and Pine Creek. New expansion sites include a portion of Kenny Ranch, the aforementioned
North Star CBD, and Railroad Avenue/Idaho Maryland (serving in part the proposed East Bennett Valley complex).
The main focus of industrial expansion will be 1) the Loma Rica Industrial Park and 2) industrial infill along
Idaho Maryland Road. North Star will have a compact industrially-designated area.
Business Park development will occur as Whispering Pines "builds out," Litton Business Park develops
to its potential, and the business parks are established in each of three major annexation areas.
It is assumed that substantial areas within the three major annexation areas will be set aside for conservation
and recreational purposes. The Northerly Emphasis anticipates significant conservation/open space projects to be
developed in conjunction with residential growth, particularly within the aforementioned Brunswick/East Bennett/Freeway
triangle, and within the city limits as "infill" conservation/recreation projects. More extensive open
space set asides will occur within the three major annexation areas. Riparian corridors and recreational trails
will be planned in anticipation of new development, and implemented in conjunction with new residential and non-residential
projects.
2.4.3 Southerly Emphasis Alternative
The Southerly Emphasis assigns most new residential development to the southern portion of the Planning Area,
generally south of McKnight Way. Residential development to the north includes pre-zoned residential allocations
to Kenny Ranch and Loma Rica Ranch, and to various infill areas. No outfill units are assumed (other than for the
major annexation areas of North Star, Loma Rica Ranch and Kenny Ranch). City annexations and service extensions
are to the south, whereas most of the potential for outfill development is north of downtown.
The Southerly Emphasis includes a major new commercial area at the old Bear River Mill site, between Highway
49 and LaBarr Meadows Road. It also assumes considerable residential development in an arc from Conway Ranch/McCourtney
Road east through North Star and Berryman Ranch. Also assumed is substantial residential development on the west
side of Osborne Hill, east of LaBarr Meadows (an area presently designated for business park and planned employment
center purposes).
A characteristic of the Southerly Emphasis could be development of a "new town" south of present Grass
Valley, in which new residents could live, work, and shop without going to and through downtown and other congested
areas on a daily basis.
By making a large commercial area available, the city would stand a better chance of accommodating large commercial
establishments unable to locate on small or constrained parcels. Although economic studies do not demonstrate a
current potential for many such establishments, much can change in 20 years. To better "fit" smaller
markets and local aesthetic preferences, traditional large store retailers have begun to locate scaled-down versions
of their large establishments in smaller cities and towns nationwide. In addition, the commercial area (and its
extension south of the Planning Area) would have the potential to accommodate warehousing and similar activities,
which can be difficult to locate or disruptive elsewhere.
2.5 PROJECT OBJECTIVES
A primary project objective is to meet legal requirements for a general plan under California planning law.
California Government Code §65300 requires each city and county to prepare and adopt a comprehensive, long-term
general plan for the physical development of lands within its jurisdiction. A general plan must be reviewed and
periodically revised and updated to reflect the changing needs and values of the community. Each jurisdiction may
select a long-term horizon for its general plan revisions, usually 15 - 25 years. Grass Valley has selected a 20
year horizon. The new Grass Valley General Plan will meet legal requirements for a revised general plan
for the period 1999-2020.
In addition, the City's objectives are to:
- develop a document that establishes goals and objectives for the City's growth and development
- develop a current data base and current base mapping
- identify issues that affect the way growth and development will occur over the next 20 years
- establish a vision for the next 20 years
- develop new policies that reflect the City's goals and objectives
- develop a general plan that is internally consistent and provides the basis for implementation of the plan's
policies
|